Headlines

Comparing Game Remakes: What Developers Keep or Change

Video game remakes are a popular trend in the gaming industry. From beloved classics to modern hits, remakes breathe new life into older games, introducing them to new audiences while satisfying nostalgic fans. However, when it comes to remaking a game, developers face the challenge of deciding what to keep from the original and what to change. Striking the right balance is key to a successful remake. In this article, we will explore the elements that developers typically retain and modify in game remakes.
Keeping the Core Experience: Why Nostalgia Matters
One of the main reasons players are drawn to game remakes is nostalgia. Gamers want to relive the experiences they had with the original game, and developers often honor this by preserving the core elements that made the original special. This includes key gameplay mechanics, level design, and, often, the overall tone and style.
For instance, in the remake of Final Fantasy VII, Square J88 Enix kept the turn-based combat system that made the original game a classic, but they modernized the battle mechanics to make them more dynamic and action-oriented. Similarly, Resident Evil 2 kept the atmosphere of the original, including the creepy setting of Raccoon City, but enhanced the visuals and added new voice acting to create a more immersive experience.
Classic Soundtracks and Visuals
Soundtracks are another key element often retained in game remakes. The music in many games is iconic and central to the atmosphere. When remaking a game, developers often choose to remaster the original soundtrack to match modern technology, but the core themes and melodies remain the same. The same is true for visual design. While developers update the graphics to meet current standards, they often aim to preserve the artistic vision of the original game. Classic games like The Legend of Zelda: Link’s Awakening retained its vibrant and whimsical art style, while updating the graphics to a charming, toy-like design that felt fresh yet familiar.
What Gets Changed: Modernizing the Experience
While keeping the essence of the original game is important, developers often feel the need to change certain elements to modernize the experience and appeal to today’s gaming audience. Game mechanics, controls, and even story elements may be altered to improve the overall experience.
Updating Controls and User Interface
One of the most common changes in game remakes is the user interface (UI) and controls. Older games often have clunky controls that don’t hold up well in modern gaming, leading developers to improve or overhaul the system. For example, in Shadow of the Colossus, the controls were updated to be more fluid and responsive, making the gameplay more accessible to modern players while staying true to the original mechanics.
Likewise, in remakes like Spyro Reignited Trilogy, developers kept the feel of the original game but adapted the controls to be smoother and more intuitive. The improvements to the UI and controls not only help with gameplay but also make the game more enjoyable for newcomers who may not be familiar with older gaming conventions.
Adding or Altering Story Elements
Sometimes, developers make changes to the storyline or characters to provide new context or improve the narrative. While remakes are generally loyal to the source material, they may add additional content or tweak the plot for better pacing or character development. This is particularly true for remakes of older games that may have had limitations due to hardware or time constraints.
In Final Fantasy VII Remake, for example, while the overarching plot remained the same, developers expanded on side stories and characters to offer a more detailed world and greater emotional depth. The expanded content not only enhances the narrative but also provides a deeper connection to the characters and events of the game.
New Features and Technology
Another area where developers often make significant changes is in the technology and features they incorporate into the remake. The introduction of new technologies allows developers to implement features that were not possible in the original. For example, in the Crash Bandicoot N. Sane Trilogy, the developers enhanced the original levels with new lighting, improved animations, and a smoother frame rate. The remakes of Final Fantasy VII and Resident Evil 2 also benefited from modern graphics engines, which enabled developers to create more realistic character models and environments.
Additionally, online multiplayer modes or new gameplay mechanics may be added to remakes. For example, in Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary, new multiplayer modes were introduced alongside remastered visuals and audio to attract both new players and fans of the original.
The Balance Between Old and New
When it comes to game remakes, the most successful titles are those that strike a balance between staying true to the original and introducing meaningful changes. Preserving the core gameplay, visuals, and sound that made the original game a classic is important for nostalgia, but introducing updated controls, features, and narrative expansions helps to keep the experience fresh and exciting for modern players.
Player Feedback and Community Involvement
A key factor in this balancing act is player feedback. Game developers often listen closely to the community’s response when creating remakes. For example, the Resident Evil 2 remake was influenced heavily by fan expectations. Developers worked hard to retain the survival-horror elements that fans loved while updating the gameplay to make it more accessible for newer audiences. In some cases, fan input can even influence which aspects of a game remain the same or get changed, allowing for a more collaborative approach to remakes.
Conclusion
Game remakes are a unique opportunity for developers to revisit classic titles and present them to new generations. The challenge lies in maintaining the essence of the original while making changes that enhance the overall experience. Whether it’s updating visuals, modifying gameplay mechanics, or tweaking the story, the best remakes carefully balance nostalgia with modern innovation, creating experiences that both honor the past and embrace the future.